Color Ideas

Can Sherwin Williams Change Paint Color After Mixed?

Written by

Rosanne Jones

Writer, Designer


Steven D. Carrico


can sherwin williams change paint color

Mixing paint bought to come up with the custom colors wanted is an exciting challenge. However, it could also lead to regret when the outcome is messed up and brutally unpleasant.

But don’t panic; you can fix the wrong paint color mixture by following the advice from experts.

The question is, can Sherwin Williams change paint color? The good news is you can tint the mixture to lighten the color, adjust the shades to make it darker, or deepen the hues to make the color radiate rather than throwing it as a waste.

Below are methods on how Sherwin Williams can change the paint color. They’re what you need in this situation.

How Sherwin Williams Retint Paint Color

Sherwin Williams retint paint in the most pleasing way. In most cases, they follow the customer’s preferred color.

This culture integrated into their services accompanied their quality paints to become one of the best in the paint industry.

Give them a call on their customer service hotline to seek advice. Their customer service representative asks you for detailed information about the paint to be retinted before making any changes. Here is how they do it:

1. Extract Detailed Information


This is the most important part of the process; their representative will be asking for detailed information about the paint and how you wanted it to be retinted. Sharing the idea you have in mind gives them a lead to follow.

2. Evaluate Paint


This involves assessing the paint and its condition. They scrutinize the factors that may affect the retinting process and are particularly keen to determine the colors involved in the mixture to ensure the retinted paint comes out the way you wanted.

3. Select New Color


Now, their color-matching expertise enters this phase. They can select the exact colors needed on the retinting process based on the details they extracted from you and their long years of tested formulation process.

4. Reformulation of the Paint


Here is the exciting part, the retinting of paint which is done in minutes. The Sherwin Williams representative will begin the reformulation of the paint in front of your eyes, so you are assured of the quality of the separation, but the chunks are soft to be mixed

  • No mold and rust formed inside or over the paint
  • No rancid or sour smell
  • No bubbles when stirred.

Tips to Lighten and Darken Paint Colors


Here are the easy tips on how to change the color of paint to come up with the desired customized color.

1. Lighten the Color

You can tint white paint to any color to lighten the paint shade and maintain the savor of the original color. The amount of white paint added determines the brightness or darkness of the tint.


Let’s use the tint of blue of Sherwin Williams paint as a specific example.

  • When a significant amount of white paint is added to the blue paint, it produces a pale light shade of Minor blue (SW 6792)
  • However, with a small amount of white color mixed with blue, it gives us a subtle, muted shade of sky fall blue (SW 9049).

Most homeowners mix primer with paint to lighten the color of the paint they want. When you decide to do this, it is recommended to settle for high-quality primer.

So, before mixing, reading the following tips on tinting gives you peace of mind later.

 01 Add Color Gradually


A common mistake for first-timers is to dump all the white paint and the proportion of colored paint they read on the internet in a mixing bucket, only to find out after mixing that it was not the right tint they wanted.

The ideal thing to do is to add color to white paint in a gradual amount until you come up with the right lightness of the color.

 02 Mix Properly


Another key point to observe when tinting is to mix the colors properly. Make sure the swirling rod reaches every corner and area of the bucket. Swirl the mixture continuously until every drop is evenly mixed.

Once this is not done properly, an imbalance of color happens, and as much as possible we do not want to deal with it.

2. Darken the Paint

There are two ways to darken paint colors. Either you intensify the shade or tone; or intensify the hue color of the base paint.

 01 Intensify Shade or Tone


To intensify the shade or tone of paint means to mix black or gray paint on the base color. This should be done with utmost care and a calculated amount. A drop of black paint is surprisingly overwhelming that it could override the original colors.

Black paint is appropriately mixed with deep colors. It establishes a commanding presence that enriches the overtone color of the paint.

Meanwhile, gray paint is used when working with light paint colors. Its light tone gives a slightly darker shade without quashing the base color.

 02 Intensify the Hue


Adding more hue to a tinted paint aims to enrich and elaborate the solid color of the paint. As observed, the pure pigmented colorant dominates tint and shades when mixed together.

For instance, you have light orange colored paint with you but want a more intensified orange feel. To do this, add a speck of deep red hue to the light orange paint at a time until you get the right orange color.

Here are some tips you should know before darkening paint colors:

    • Use the same brand – each brand comes with a unique formula of its own which may be incompatible with other brands. This can lead to unfavorable cramping of the combined paints.
    • Identify the undertone – it pays much to know the undertone of the color you’re working with to avoid messing up during paint darkening.

Things to Consider for Right Color Mix


Trying to change paint color once mixed is like repairing a cooked recipe. You must play with fire, seasonings, and water to get the taste.

In painting, you can also avert the crisis of the wrong paint mixture by playing with its four color variations. Once you understand how these four work, you can adjust any color to your liking.

  • Tint – You can add white to any colors in the color wheel to desaturate and lighten the paint color. Its scope ranges from a drop of white paint to as many as you want to add. All colored paints with white paint added are called tinted paint.
  • Shade – Shade is the term for adding black color to any shades in the color wheel. This color variation is the right choice to change paint colors on walls for a more intense and darker version.
  • Tone – When you opt to use neutral gray to darken paint colors instead of black, you are actually doing a tone.
  • Hue – These are the primary and secondary colors in the color wheel. Intensifying a hue color means adding more hue color to make the base paint more vivid.

If you have noticed, “colors in the color wheels” is reiterated above because black, gray, and white are not found there. These colors are technically not true colors, and they belong to achromatic colors. Their presence defines neutrality, the absence of light(back), and the reflection of all lights(white).

Frequently Asked Questions


How much does it cost to mix Sherwin Williams paint?

Sherwin Williams charges a reasonable fee for mixing paints to your desired colors. Their product is often rated from $40 – over $100 per gallon. It also depends on the volume amount and the type of paint you want them to mix.

What to do if you don’t like the paint color?

First, when you do not want the paint color you bought, you can bring it back to the shop to exchange it with the color you wanted to be provided that it FALLS under the condition on the return policy. For Sherwin Williams, the return policy covers 30 days upon purchase.

Secondly, aside from throwing it in the recycling plant, which costs you a disposal fee, you can retint, add shades, or add colorant to the paint to come up with a new color you desire.


The variation of hues dictates the essence of the lightening and darkening of colors while giving a fresh visual appeal. Thus, they must be considered when deciding to change paint color on walls. Also, tinted paint and darkened ones are easy to maintain, and it’s more affordable too.

Can Sherwin Williams change paint color? The answer is yes. The color matching technology of Sherwin Williams can change the paint to meet their customers’ needs. In case you are dealing with colors that are hard to tint, Sherwin Williams has an open line to ask for advice or go to their nearest store location and have your paint assessed.

5/5 - (2 votes)